Cyberstalking is a significant challenge in the era of Internet and technology. When dealing with cyberstalking, institutions and governments alike have a problem in how to manage it and where to allocate resources. Hence, it is important to understand how individuals feel about the problem of cyberstalking and how it can be managed in the context of cybersecurity. In this paper we systematically interviewed over 100 individuals to interpret their values on cyberstalking. Keeney’s [21] value focused thinking approach is then used to convert individual values into objectives which form the basis for planning to curb cyberstalking and for institutions and governments to allocate resources prudently.